appealing an admissions rejection -- Virtually Advising Q+A

The Q: What is the best approach for appealing a rejection to admissions at a major public university? We understand the rejection was due to lack of complete information regarding extracurricular activities. GPA and academics are excellent.

The A: I'm not sure I have enough information to be of help. For instance, how do you know what the basis of the rejection might be? What would constitute a "lack of complete information regarding extracurricular activities"? (Didn't you or your child fill out the forms?)

My understanding is that admissions appeals are rarely successful. Most parents and students assume that admissions are formulaic (i.e., if I have enough activities, grades, scores, etc., I'm a shoe-in), but in fact it's more complicated. That's why applications ask for personal statements and letters. Even at the graduate school level, I was accepted places I didn't expect to be, and not in programs I thought I was perfect for. You can't second-guess these things.

All of that having been said, here's how to appeal. Write directly to the Dean or Director of Admissions at the school, stating that you believe the decision may have been made on the grounds of incomplete information and ask to meet with her/him. Write a short but effective letter. Then wait; if they will hear your appeal, they'll call to discuss it and possibly follow up with an appointment. Just don't be overly adamant -- or hopeful.

Best of luck,

—Anahid Kassabian, Chief Advisor